Suggested Fines

The following table of suggested fines is intended as a guideline for the independent adjudicator during adjudication of an ISPA Code of Conduct complaint. It is not intended as a prescribed sanction, nor is it an indication that an adjudicated complaint will result in the sanctions or fines suggested below. Fines are only one of the possible sanctions available to adjudicators, and it is not obligatory for an adjudicator to impose a fine for a specific breach.

# Clause in Code v3.1 Minimum fine per offense Maximum fine per offense Notes
A1 Applicability to services Not applicable Not applicable
A2 Applicability to divisions Not applicable Not applicable
B3 Freedom of Expression R 0.00 R42,000.00
C4 Privacy R 0.00 R42,000.00
C5 Confidentiality R 1,750.00 R42,000.00
D6 Information on websites R 3,500.00 Minimum x no. of months in breach
Maximum of six months
E7 Informing customers R 3,500.00 Minimum x no. of months in breach
Maximum of six months
E8 Acceptable/fair use R 3,500.00 Minimum x no. of months in breach
Maximum of six months
E9 Requires policies R 3,500.00 R24,000.00
Maximum of six months
E10 Fair dealing R 0.00 R42,000.00
Refund also recommended where applicable
E11 Service levels R 0.00 R42,000.00
E12 Advertising standards R 0.00 R10,500.00
F13 Availability of Ts&Cs R 3,500.00 Minimum x no. of months in breach
Maximum of six months
F14 Right to remove content R 3,500.00 Minimum x no. of months in breach
Maximum of six months
F15 Suspend or Terminate R 3,500.00 Minimum x no. of months in breach
Maximum of six months
G16 Spam R 3,500.00 R42,000.00
G17 Spam complaints R 3,500.00 R21,000.00
H18 Cybercrime R 0.00 R21,000.00
I19 Paid services to minors R 3,500.00 R21,000.00
I20 Filtering software R 3,500.00 Minimum x no. of months in breach
Maximum of six months
I21 Court directive processes R 0.00 R21,000.00
No fine previously set for this clause
I22 FPB Act processes R 0.00 R21,000.00
No fine previously set for this clause
J23 Lawful conduct R 0.00 R42,000.00
J24 Intellectual property R 0.00 R21,000.00
J25 Abide by Code R 0.00 R42,000.00
K26 No monitoring R 0.00 R21,000.00
K27 Must not knowingly host R 0.00 R 3,500.00
K28 Suspend or terminate R 3,500.00 R21,000.00
K29 Notice & takedown R 3,500.00 Minimum x no. of months in breach
Maximum of six months
K30 Report to ISPA R 3,500.00 R21,000.00
K31 Keep records R 0.00 R21,000.00
L32 Voluntary codes R 0.00 R21,000.00
No fine previously set for this clause
M33 Complaints R 0.00 R21,000.00
M34 Resolve complaints R 0.00 R42,000.00
M35 Cooperate with ISPA R 0.00 R42,000.00
M36 Annual Statement R 3,500.00 R21,000.00
M37 Audit Not applicable Not applicable
M38 Investigate Not applicable Not applicable
N39 Make changes Not applicable Not applicable